Top 12 Colby Cheese

We often use several different types of cheese for cooking depending on the recipe, but the most common ones are processed cheese cubes, cheddar, and mozzarella. However, some kinds of cheese are not typically used for cooking but are instead used as a table cheese, which can either be eaten alone as a snack or paired with wine. Colby cheese, also referred to as Colby Swiss Cheddar, is a famous American cheese made from cow milk, and even though it has cheddar in its other name, it is nothing like cheddar cheese.

Browse Best Colby Cheese

Sargento Foods Colby Jack Reduced Fat String Cheese, 9 oz, 9 oz

  • Brand Name: Sargento
  • Model Name: 46100007426
  • Satisfaction Score: 99%
  • Dimensions: 7.75 x 2.55 x 2.55 inches; 8.96 Ounces
  • Overall Score: 9.5
Store Website: www.amazon.com

Colby Cheese Longhorn 48oz Half Loaf

  • Brand Name: Wisconsin cheese
  • Item Weight: 2.5 Pounds
  • Satisfaction Score: 92%
  • Overall Score: 9.1
Store Website: www.amazon.com

Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Sliced Colby Jack Cheese, 10 Slices, 8 Ounce

  • Brand Name: Happy Belly
  • Satisfaction Score: 99%
  • Dimensions: 5.25 x 1 x 8.75 inches; 8 Ounces
  • Overall Score: 9.3
Store Website: www.amazon.com

Sargento Colby-Jack Natural Cheese Ultra Thin Slices, 20 slices

  • Brand Name: Sargento
  • Satisfaction Score: 100%
  • Dimensions: 0.75 x 5.75 x 9 inches; 7.6 Ounces
  • Overall Score: 9.5
Store Website: www.amazon.com

365 by Whole Foods Market, Cheese Bar, Colby Jack, 8 Ounce

  • Brand Name: 365 by Whole Foods Market
  • Satisfaction Score: 98%
  • Dimensions: 5.5 x 2.75 x 0.88 inches; 8 Ounces
  • Overall Score: 9.3
Store Website: www.amazon.com

Shullsburg Creamery - Colby Cheese - 1 Pound

  • Brand Name: Shullsburg Creamery
  • Item Weight: 1 Pounds
  • Satisfaction Score: 100%
  • Overall Score: 9.9
Store Website: www.amazon.com

Kraft Natural Colby Jack Finely Shredded Cheese (8 oz Bag)

  • Brand Name: Kraft Foods
  • Model Name: mburring
  • Satisfaction Score: 98%
  • Dimensions: 1 x 6.5 x 8.75 inches; 7.2 Ounces
  • Overall Score: 9.5
Store Website: www.amazon.com

Tillamook Colby Jack Cheese Slices, 12 oz (Packaging May Vary)

  • Brand Name: Tillamook
  • Model Name: 12833
  • Satisfaction Score: 100%
  • Dimensions: 3.9 x 1.6 x 3.7 inches; 12 Ounces
  • Overall Score: 9.5
Store Website: www.amazon.com

365 Everyday Value, Colby Jack Cheese, Slices, 12 oz

  • Brand Name: 365 Everyday Value
  • Satisfaction Score: 88%
  • Dimensions: 1.25 x 6 x 11 inches; 12 Ounces
  • Overall Score: 8.7
Store Website: www.amazon.com

Tillamook Medium, Sharp, Swiss & Colby Jack Sliced Cheese Sampler

  • Brand Name: Tillamook
  • Satisfaction Score: 90%
  • Overall Score: 8.1
Store Website: www.amazon.com

Amazon Brand - Happy Belly Colby Jack Cheese Block, 8 Ounce

  • Brand Name: Happy Belly
  • Satisfaction Score: 98%
  • Dimensions: 6.75 x 1 x 2.5 inches; 8 Ounces
  • Overall Score: 9.1
Store Website: www.amazon.com

365 Everyday Value, Organic Colby Jack Cheese, Slices, 12 oz

  • Brand Name: 365 Everyday Value
  • Satisfaction Score: 100%
  • Dimensions: 9.6 x 7.8 x 15.8 inches; 12 Ounces
  • Overall Score: 9.3
Store Website: www.amazon.com

Colby Cheese Buying Guide

Colby cheese is semi-hard in texture and has a yellow or orange color similar to cheddar cheese, and is quite soft and creamy. It is made with a washed-curd process, which reduces the moisture and acid level, giving it a mild taste. Colby cheese’s mild flavor is the reason it is famous as a snack and table cheese. However, it also tastes well in sandwiches and can be used as a creamy topping for salads, but it can lose its flavor when cooked. But whichever way you use Colby cheese, you should keep a few points in mind before buying it.

Which to Choose: Slices, Block, or Shredded?

Since Colby cheese is served as a snack or on cheese platters, you will most likely find sliced pieces or a loaf shape that can be easily sliced. Slices can be quite convenient for serving guests and also for adding to sandwiches. If you buy a block of Colby cheese, you can easily cut it up into small pieces at home or use it however you like.

Shredded Colby cheese is a ready-to-use variation, primarily if you use it to top salads or other dishes like pasta. However, there is one other exciting option – Colby cheese sticks, which are excellent for snacking, especially for kids. But ultimately, the choice is yours.

Good-Quality Milk and Ingredients are Essential

Colby cheese is made from cow milk, and so, its taste is mostly dependent on the milk quality. Therefore, it is better to choose fresh, pasteurized milk, which is not produced by giving cows any antibiotics or rBST. The cheese should be one hundred percent natural or organic, and even if there is added color, it should be plant-based and not artificial. Buyers who are vegetarian or vegan can go with vegan Colby cheese, which contains no animal rennet. The Colby cheese you choose should also be non-GMO certified for extra caution.

Packaging and More

Freshness is essential for cheese, and to ensure freshness, packaging plays an important role. It is always better to go with resealable packets, so you do not have to worry about the cheese going bad, especially if using little at a time. Some brands offer zip-lock bags, which are all the more convenient. If you buy Colby cheese sticks, you should check for individual, pocket-sized packing, which is easier to carry. Those who are worried about Colby cheese’s high-calorie count can choose reduced/low-fat string cheese, which has fewer calories and more protein.