Top Butter Maid Bakery Alternatives and Similar Sites like buttermaidbakery.com

Butter Maid Bakery United States buttermaidbakery.com
Popularity 1.6/10

Butter Maid Bakery, a cherished family-owned establishment since 1955, honors a rich tradition of baking with high-quality, simple ingredients. With over 150 years of experience, our handmade pastries evoke nostalgia, connecting generations through the flavors that have graced family tables since our founding in Ohio.

Butter Maid BakeryVisit site

Butter Maid Bakery alternatives

Instya is reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you shop through links on this page.

New English Muffin Co

New English Muffin Co crafts exceptional English muffins, renowned for their distinct texture and flavor.

Popularity 7.3/10
Partner

Sprinkles

Sprinkles is dedicated to crafting delightful baked goods that elevate any occasion.

Popularity 8.3/10
Partner

David's Cookies

Makes cookies, brownies, cheesecakes and other baked desserts in its own bakery, with gift baskets, gluten-free options and kosher-certified products.

Popularity 6.2/10
Partner

Einsteinbros

Fresh-baked bagels and breakfast egg sandwiches set this chain apart, with bagels baked in each bakery and paired with cold brew and iced coffee for morning customers.

Popularity 9.2/10

Magnolia Bakery

At Magnolia Bakery, customers can enjoy a variety of delightful desserts, with options for local pickup or nationwide shipping.

Popularity 9.0/10

Levain Bakery

Levain Bakery, established in 1995, has become renowned for its exceptional, freshly baked cookies, characterized by a crispy exterior and a warm, gooey center.

Popularity 9.0/10

Wildgrain

Households and gift-givers who want bread, pastries and pasta baked at home can order frozen boxes from Wildgrain.

Popularity 8.6/10

Porto's Bakery

Cake lovers and pastry buyers in Southern California can order from Porto's Bakery & Cafe, which runs six locations and ships its cakes and pastries across the US.

Popularity 8.5/10

Dewey's Bakery

Dewey’s Bakery, rooted in tradition since 1930, crafts delightful treats including thin, flavorful cookies and cherished Moravian sugar cake.

Popularity 3.2/10

Cookie Bouquets

Each arrangement is a charming blend of flavors, beautifully packaged for any occasion...

Breadsmith Franchising

Each loaf is meticulously handmade from high-quality ingredients, baked in a five-ton European hearth stone...

Popularity 3.9/10

Southern Baked Pie Company

Choose your preferred flavors and ship date to ensure a timely arrival, all carefully packaged...

Di Camillo Bakery

The bakery also crafts beloved regional treats such as peanut stick donuts and kummelweck rolls...

Kontos Foods Inc

emerged from a legacy of traditional baking, rooted in the hand-stretched techniques of fillo dough...

Last Crumb

Our handcrafted cookies are meticulously developed over three days, blending unique flavors and textures...

Popularity 3.7/10

Toufayan Bakeries

Since 1926, the Toufayan family has perfected their recipes, ensuring that each loaf and wrap...

Popularity 3.4/10

Aunt Millie's Bakeries

Its line includes artisan-style loaves, Live Carb Smart products and Hawaiian Dinner Rolls, aimed at...

Popularity 4.5/10

Turano Baking Company

Renowned for its diverse range of high-quality specialty breads and rolls, Turano enriches culinary experiences...

Popularity 1.7/10

Company Information

Company Name: Butter Maid Bakery

Location: United States

Top Butter Maid Bakery Product Options

  • Nut Rolls
  • Kolachi
  • Cinnamon Rolls
  • Homemade Muffins
  • Fresh Baked Pies
  • Classic Cheesecake
  • Rich Brownies
  • Assorted Cookies
  • Sweet Cream Butter Cookies
  • Pecan Pie
  • Walnut Rolls
  • Seasonal Baked Goods
  • Apple Cinnamon Kolachi
  • Chocolate Chip Cookies
  • Lemon Bars
  • Pumpkin Roll
  • Strawberry Shortcake
  • Old-Fashioned Fruitcake
  • Birthday Cake
  • Holiday Cookie Tray
  • Croissant
  • Biscotti
  • Chocolate Cream Pie
  • Blueberry Muffins
  • Raspberry Kolachi
  • Peanut Butter Cookies
  • Almond Biscotti
  • Maple Pecan Kolachi
  • Carrot Cake
  • Cherry Pie
  • Red Velvet Cake