
Top Door County Creamery Alternatives and Similar Sites like doorcountycreamery.com
Based in downtown Sister Bay, Door County Creamery is a goat farmstead and creamery that makes goat cheese, gelato and soap, with an eatery on site. It suits cheese lovers and chefs, and it offers wholesale accounts for buyers who want larger quantities.
Door County Creamery alternatives
Instya is reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you shop through links on this page.
Cheese Grotto
Discover Cheese Grotto, where artisan cheese meets expert storage solutions...
TheMeatery.com
TheMeatery.com offers premium meats sourced from reputable suppliers, ensuring top-quality selections.
Effie's Homemade
Effie’s Homemade biscuits celebrate a cherished farmhouse tradition with a modern twist.
Murray's Cheese
Murray's Cheese is a renowned destination for cheese lovers, showcasing an extensive selection of artisanal cheeses and charcuterie.
Cabot Creamery
Makes cheese, butter, Greek yogurt and other dairy products from milk supplied by farm families in New England and New York, selling cheddar blocks, shredded and snacking cheese, gift boxes and apparel to cheese buyers and gift shoppers..
Cowgirl Creamery
Cowgirl Creamery champions the art of cheese-making, sourcing exceptional milk from local farms to create artisanal cheeses.
Rebel Cheese
Makes plant-based cheeses from nut milk in Austin, Texas, including cave-aged brie, spreads and holiday gift boxes.
Cheese Brothers
Cheese Brothers crafts exquisite, handmade cheeses from the heart of Wisconsin, celebrating a brotherhood of flavor and quality.
Fiscalini Farmstead
Fiscalini Farmstead, rooted in Swiss cheese-making traditions, crafts artisanal cheeses by hand, emphasizing quality and flavor.
Cheesemonger Box
Each box includes thoughtfully chosen cuts and pairing suggestions, allowing enthusiasts to savor unique flavors...
Brazos Valley Cheese
Visitors can enjoy a view through a large observation window while learning about the cheese-making...
Veldhuizen Cheese Shoppe
With a commitment to traditional methods, each batch undergoes careful, low-temperature processing, ensuring rich flavors...
Caputo Brothers Creamery
The unique fermentation process imparts a distinct tanginess, evoking memories of Italy...
Big Island Little Cheese
Visitors can indulge in artisanal cheeses and butters, attend engaging cheese classes, and enjoy complimentary...
Beehive Cheese Company, BLLC
Renowned for their rich, buttery textures, their award-winning creations reflect a deep commitment to quality...
Boomkampkaas
Customers can conveniently order a diverse range of exquisite cheeses, artisanal sausages, and gourmet delicacies...
Decatur Dairy Inc
Renowned for award-winning selections like Havarti and Muenster, the third-generation cheesemaker Steve Stettler expertly produces...
Maytag Dairy Farms
Each product is meticulously handcrafted and cave-aged, enveloped in distinctive silver and blue foil, celebrating...
Info About Door County Creamery & Door County Creamery Store
Few cheese shops milk their own goats, but this one does. Door County Creamery runs a goat farm and creamery, and the goat milk goes into chèvre, aged cheddar, gelato and soap. The Johnson family's flock began with 11 Nubian and La Mancha goats, breeds valued for milk with higher butterfat that suits cheese and gelato. Jesse, the licensed cheesemaker, was inspired by a goat farmstead he visited in Avignon, France, and the business opened in downtown Sister Bay in 2013. Rachael is the soap and gelato maker.
The cheese list draws on local and regional flavors. Chèvre comes with truffle, toasted onion, jalapeño and pimento, and one version uses foraged wild ramps, which grow only for a few weeks each spring. Lingonberry and cherry chèvres nod to Scandinavian heritage and the cherries grown in Door County. Communion, a goat cheddar, is made only with unpasteurized spring milk and aged in an earthy red wine brine. Several chèvres were listed as sold out at the time of review. Buyers interested in wholesale can request an account by email for 5-pound vacuum-sealed tubs of plain chèvre.
Company Information
Company Name: DOOR COUNTY CREAMERY
Location: SISTER BAY, Wisconsin, United States
Top Door County Creamery Product Options
- Farmstead goat dairy
- Nubian and La Mancha goats
- Goat milk chèvre
- Wild ramp chèvre
- Communion red wine brine cheddar
- Unpasteurized spring milk cheese
- Goat milk gelato
- Goat milk soap
- 5-pound vacuum-sealed tubs



