Top My Cookie Dealer Alternatives and Similar Sites like mycookiedealer.com

My Cookie Dealer United States mycookiedealer.com

My Cookie Dealer sells protein-fortified cookies and toaster-style pastries, with gourmet cookies in the same lineup and new limited-edition flavors released weekly. It suits snackers who want treats with added protein, and it offers STAY FRESH branded apparel.

My Cookie DealerVisit site

My Cookie Dealer alternatives

Instya is reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you shop through links on this page.

Yum Yum Candy Shop

Based in Idaho, Yum Yum Candy Shop sells freeze-dried candy, gooey gummies, sour candy powders and candy bundles across the United States.

Partner

Koeze Company

Koeze Company is dedicated to exceptional customer service, ensuring satisfaction through quality products and timely support.

Store Website: koeze.com|Alternatives
Partner

Swizzels

Swizzels, established in 1928, is renowned for creating iconic sweets like Love Hearts and Drumsticks.

Popularity 3.9/10
Partner

Insomnia Cookies

Insomnia Cookies caters to late-night cravings by bringing warm, freshly baked cookies directly to your doorstep.

Popularity 9.2/10

Tate's Bake Shop

Cookies, bakery items and gift baskets sold online by Tate's Bake Shop, a Southampton, New York bakery, for gifting, parties, weddings and corporate orders.

Popularity 8.5/10

Eleni's New York

For over 25 years, Eleni's New York has crafted exquisite cookies that have become beloved staples in homes and at celebrations.

Popularity 3.6/10

Collettey's Cookies

Collettey's Cookies, founded by the tenacious Collette, champions the employment of individuals with disabilities.

Popularity 2.7/10

Dirty Dough

At Dirty Dough, we embrace the delightful chaos of life with our uniquely crafted cookies.

Popularity 2.7/10

Halfsies Cookie Company

Bargain Bird Food provides a wide selection of high-quality bird food, including sunflower hearts, seed mixes, peanuts, suets, and mealworms.

PDX Cookie Co

Enjoy our rotating monthly cookie subscription, featuring 12 unique flavors delivered to your door, and...

Ham N Goodys

Known for their iconic Lemon Cookies, they also support fundraising initiatives for schools and sports...

Matt's Cookie Company

Each seasonal variety blends unique flavors, from minty peppermint to spiced gingerbread, delivering a soft-baked...

Jenny Bakery Hong Kong

The cookies are free of preservatives and coloring, and the brand targets gift buyers and...

RubySnap Fresh Cookies

This delightful treat features a perfectly balanced blend of toasted walnuts and decadent chocolate, all...

Biscotti Cavanna

The range includes traditional biscuits, a beer made with Granda brewery, gift boxes and aprons...

Tiger Schulmann's Martial Arts

Each delicious, homemade cookie sold contributes to job creation and community empowerment...

Store Website: tsk.com|Alternatives
Popularity 6.2/10

The Cookie Mail

Each cookie is thoughtfully packaged in letterbox-friendly boxes, ensuring a delightful experience for recipients across...

Biscuits Bredaland

Accommodations range from cozy studios to spacious homes, ideal for couples, families, or gatherings...

Info About My Cookie Dealer & My Cookie Dealer Store

The Frosted Apple Pie Protein Pastry is one of the store's toaster-style pastries, and the store describes it as having 20g of protein. The protein line includes Frosted Strawberry, Frosted Blueberry and Frosted Hot Fudge Sundae pastries, plus protein cookies in Snack Size, 25g and Bite Sized formats. Flavors such as Milk & Cookies, Chocolate Candy Ganache and Peanut Butter & Jelly appear across the protein cookies.

Gourmet cookies are sold as single cookies, a 12 pack and a half-pound size, and many flavors rotate through limited-edition drops. Names such as OG, Funfetti, PB2 and Carrot Cake sit in the regular lineup, while seasonal flavors like Wicked Pumpkin and Witches Brew appear in the Soft Baked and Halloween selections. All cookies are baked fresh, and unconsumed cookies should be frozen. The store is Female Owned and lists retail partners including Vitamin Shoppe, GNC, Academy Sports and QuickChek.

Apparel is limited to STAY FRESH sweatshirts and tees, including a crest embroidered crew and a flocked NY crew neck. Ground shipping through UPS typically takes five business days, and orders placed after 2pm EST ship the next business day. Orders placed on weekends ship Monday. Cookies cannot be cancelled or returned, while unworn clothing can be returned within 14 days, and PO Boxes are not served.

More Popular Products from My Cookie Dealer

Prices as of 31 Oct 2026; check the store for current prices.

Company Information

Company Name: My Cookie Dealer

Location: New Orleans, Louisiana, United States

Founded in: 2019

Top My Cookie Dealer Product Options

  • Protein toaster pastries with 20g protein
  • Weekly limited edition cookie drops
  • Half-pound gourmet cookies
  • Snack size protein cookies
  • Bite sized protein cookies
  • Soft Baked cookie line
  • STAY FRESH embroidered sweatshirts
  • Flocked NY crew neck sweatshirts
  • UPS ground and two-day shipping