Top Olio Olive Oils & Balsamics Alternatives and Similar Sites like oliooliveoil.com

Olio Olive Oils & Balsamics United States oliooliveoil.com

Olive oils and balsamic vinegars are the main stock at this family-owned shop in Lititz, Pennsylvania, which has been operating since 2012. It suits home cooks and food lovers who want artisan flavors, with gourmet pantry goods and gifts available.

Olio Olive Oils & BalsamicsVisit site

Olio Olive Oils & Balsamics alternatives

Instya is reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you shop through links on this page.

Dave's Gourmet

Dave's Gourmet, established in 1993, excels in creating award-winning hot sauces and pasta sauces.

Popularity 4.1/10
Partner

Effie's Homemade

Effie’s Homemade biscuits celebrate a cherished farmhouse tradition with a modern twist.

Partner

Portugalia Marketplace

Portuguese specialty food grocer selling conservas, salt cod, cured meats, cheeses, olive oil and over 1300 Portuguese wines, plus Portuguese design and home goods.

Popularity 2.0/10
Partner

Garrett Popcorn Shops

Popcorn fans and gift buyers who want handmade gourmet snacks will find Garrett Popcorn Shops, a Chicago business known for copper-kettle popcorn in flavors such as CaramelCrisp and CheeseCorn.

Popularity 8.9/10

Equal Exchange

Sources fair trade and organic coffee, chocolate, tea, cocoa and snacks directly from small-scale farmers and their co-ops, shipping within the United States to households and organizations, including by the case.

Popularity 8.5/10

SupermarketItaly.com

At SupermarketItaly.com, enjoy free shipping on orders over $99, even for perishable items.

Popularity 8.5/10

Marky's

Indulge in a luxurious Easter celebration with 10% OFF select caviars, gourmet meats, and an array of desserts using code EASTER.

Popularity 8.5/10

iGourmet

Enter your email to receive timely notifications when this exquisite product is back in stock.

Popularity 7.8/10

Pasolivo Olive Oil

Pasolivo Olive Oil embodies culinary artistry, enhancing dishes with its robust flavors and high-quality ingredients.

Popularity 2.4/10

Sentir Cubano

Immerse yourself in the vibrant culture and flavors of Cuba, all available at your fingertips...

Popularity 2.7/10

Il Porcellino Salumi

Each product, from salami to coppa, is meticulously handmade, ensuring a unique blend of old-world...

Hi Country

With a commitment to sustainable practices and a "whole cow philosophy," their products are perfect...

Texas Pepper Jelly

Award-winning varieties pair seamlessly with everything from pork to vegetables...

Frontier Soups | Anderson House

Each blend is designed for ease of preparation, ensuring hearty, flavorful meals that bring families...

Popularity 1.6/10

Bemka - Caviar Lover

With a commitment to quality and exceptional customer service, each variety tantalizes the palate, making...

Eurofoodmart

Customers can enjoy a diverse array of flavors and high-quality goods sourced from various European...

Popularity 2.2/10

Twisted Alchemy

Now available in the produce section of Whole Foods Markets across the Midwest and Southwest...

Bunzel’s Catering

It serves Milwaukee families and caterers from a family-owned meat market with a deli and...

Info About Olio Olive Oils & Balsamics & Olio Olive Oils & Balsamics Store

Olio's shop in downtown Lititz, Pennsylvania stocks more than 130 flavors of artisan olive oils and balsamic vinegars, a selection that is large for a single shop. Flavors range from Meyer Lemon EVOO and Tuscan Herb EVOO to Fig Balsamic and Lemon Cucumber White Balsamic. Balsamic vinegars come from Modena, Italy, while the olive oils are sourced from producers across the globe. Each oil and vinegar is selected for quality, flavor and authenticity. Family ownership has shaped the business since it was established in 2012, and the shop pairs a local boutique feel with a large retail selection.

Apart from oils and vinegars, the shop sells gourmet sea salts, peppercorns and rubs, along with cookbooks and bath and body products. Gift baskets are custom-crafted and are offered as a gift option. A tap room at the shop offers complimentary tastings, letting buyers sample oils and vinegars before choosing a bottle. Recipes are published online in categories such as appetizers, desserts and main dishes.

Olive oil is rich in antioxidants and Vitamin E, and balsamic vinegar contains natural probiotics, which the shop presents as a flavorful, healthy alternative to heavy dressings and sauces. Online orders ship within the continental U.S. only. Located at 41 South Broad Street in Lititz, the shop is open Monday to Saturday from 10 AM to 5 PM.

More Popular Products from Olio Olive Oils & Balsamics

Prices as of 30 Oct 2026; check the store for current prices.

Company Information

Company Name: Olio Olive Oils & Balsamics

Location: Lititz, Pennsylvania, United States

Top Olio Olive Oils & Balsamics Product Options

  • Over 130 olive oil and balsamic flavors
  • Modena balsamic vinegars from Italy
  • Meyer Lemon EVOO
  • Garlic and Butter EVOO
  • Lemon Cucumber White Balsamic
  • Organic gluten free rice pasta
  • Gourmet sea salts and peppercorns
  • Custom-crafted gift baskets
  • Tap room tastings