Top Riddle's Jewelry Alternatives and Similar Sites like riddlesjewelry.com

Riddle's Jewelry United States riddlesjewelry.com
Popularity 7.9/10

Jewelry, from diamond engagement rings and wedding bands to watches, necklaces and earrings, sold through more than 60 stores in 10 states and online. The family-run chain serves customers marking engagements, anniversaries, birthdays and other occasions.

Riddle's JewelryVisit site

Riddle's Jewelry alternatives

Instya is reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you shop through links on this page.

Misho Designs

Join Misho Designs for an exclusive experience, gaining access to unique content, early glimpses of upcoming collections, and a 10% discount.

Popularity 2.6/10
Partner

Gabriel &

Bridal and fine jewelry, including engagement rings, wedding bands, silver pieces and men's jewelry, made in-house at a New York atelier.

Popularity 9.2/10
Partner

Cate & Chloe Jewelry

Cate & Chloe Jewelry embodies elegance and versatility, creating timeless pieces that seamlessly transition from casual settings to formal events.

Popularity 6.4/10
Partner

Tiffany &

Tiffany & Co., established in 1837, stands as a hallmark of luxury, renowned for its exquisite jewelry and distinctive designs.

Popularity 9.9/10

Fossil

Fossil encompasses a refined collection of timepieces and accessories for both men and women, alongside an array of stylish handbags and versatile apparel such as jeans, t-shirts, sweaters, and dresses, catering to diverse tastes and lifestyle needs while enhancing everyday elegance..

Popularity 9.8/10

Blue Nile

Makes and sells engagement rings, wedding bands, loose diamonds and fine jewelry online.

Popularity 9.8/10

JTV (Jewelry Television)

Diamond, moissanite and gemstone rings lead the jewelry at JTV, short for Jewelry Television, a shopping channel that sells through live broadcasts and online.

Store Website: jtv.com|Alternatives
Popularity 9.8/10

Kay Jewelers

Stocks engagement rings, wedding bands, fine jewelry and watches from Kay Jewelers, aimed at couples, families and friends marking milestones.

Store Website: kay.com|Alternatives
Popularity 9.8/10

Anastasia Madrid

Products ship from warehouses in China. Anastasia Madrid sells women's...

Popularity 6.0/10

MARIA TASH

The brand began as a New York piercing studio and is sold online with worldwide...

Popularity 7.2/10

Getbellaandco

Each piece is designed to resist fading and rust, even in water, ensuring longevity...

Dsire Collections

The online store sells exclusive pieces to customers across the United States and, through international...

Joyería Atenea

Orders are dispatched from warehouses in China, which affects delivery times and returns...

Popularity 5.9/10

AZZI Jewelers

It also offers financing and buys Rolex watches...

Popularity 3.6/10

Rogers & Hollands

Watches from several brands are also offered...

Popularity 8.0/10

SoulZodiac

US-founded SoulZodiac sells zodiac and tarot pendant necklaces, mostly in...

Charmette

Charms cover initials, birthstones, hobbies and animals, and the store also sells Apple Watch links...

Popularity 9.3/10

Humans We Love

Each vintage ring is verified by gemologists...

Info About Riddle's Jewelry & Riddle's Jewelry Store

Black Hills Gold and the 90-facet Noventa® Diamond are the signature lines of Riddle's Jewelry, and both come from the company's factory in Rapid City, South Dakota, which also serves as its headquarters. The factory opened in 1989 and began producing Black Hills Gold along with many other diamond and gemstone styles, and it now makes many of the chain's own designs. The Noventa® Diamond has 32 more facets than a standard round cut, giving it 90 in total.

Jesse Riddle opened the first Riddle's Jewelry in Eastern South Dakota in 1959, and the business has stayed family owned and operated ever since. As it expanded across several states, each location began offering onsite repairs and custom designs. A later expansion reached 8 states and nearly 50 stores, and the second generation took the helm. Today the chain runs more than 60 stores in 10 states, and the third generation now works in the business. Online, its jewelry includes lab-grown diamonds under the Adamante name, Above Love wedding sets and EFFY pieces. Jesse Riddle often said, "We are in the love business."

More Popular Products from Riddle's Jewelry

Prices as of 2 Nov 2026; check the store for current prices.

Company Information

Location: Rapid City, South Dakota, United States

Founded in: 1959

Top Riddle's Jewelry Product Options

  • Black Hills Gold jewelry
  • Noventa® Diamond with 90 facets
  • Lab-grown diamonds under Adamante
  • Above Love wedding sets
  • EFFY jewelry
  • Sterling silver charms
  • Factory production in Rapid City
  • Onsite repairs and custom designs