Top Story Supply Co. Alternatives and Similar Sites like storysupplyco.com

Story Supply Co. United States storysupplyco.com

Makes notebooks, pencils, sketchbooks and paper goods in the U.S., using paper from a family-owned mill that runs on renewable hydro power. Graphic design and print services are available too, serving artists, writers and makers who want analog tools.

Story Supply Co.Visit site

Story Supply Co. alternatives

Instya is reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you shop through links on this page.

Silk and Sonder

Makes monthly guided journal-planners delivered by subscription, paired with a companion app, live classes and an online member community.

Popularity 5.4/10
Partner

FineStationery.com

FineStationery.com is your destination for exquisite paper goods, showcasing a curated selection from talented designers.

Popularity 7.1/10
Partner

Colorful Images

Colorful Images sells personalized return address labels, rolled address labels and personal checks, along with greeting and holiday stationery for home and office use.

Popularity 7.0/10
Partner

Store Moleskine

Join the Moleskine community and embrace the art of writing with thoughtfully designed products that celebrate creativity and craftsmanship.

Popularity 9.7/10

Envelopes.com

Based in the United States, Envelopes.com sells envelopes in many sizes, colors and finishes, along with paper, cardstock and office supplies.

Popularity 9.7/10

Tiny Prints

Tiny Prints offers modern, personalized cards and stationery that can be customized with photos, names, colors, fonts and messages.

Popularity 9.6/10

Erin Condren Design

Erin Condren Design provides an extensive array of customizable planners, including monthly, academic, and teacher planners, crafted for diverse organizational needs.

Popularity 9.3/10

Paper Papers

PaperPapers is a dedicated resource for high-quality paper and envelopes, catering to the diverse needs of artists, businesses, and creative individuals.

Popularity 9.2/10

Therapy Notebooks

Guided notebooks built on research and written with clinicians, Therapy Notebooks sells mental health tools for anxiety, depression, insomnia and everyday self-care.

The Paper Worm

Its catalogue spans notebooks, sticker packs, and character-themed bundles...

Popularity 8.8/10

Millefolium Ink

It suits people who plan, journal or design with botanical and antique-style artwork...

Vanness

Run by a third generation of the Vanness family, the business has traded since 1938...

Popularity 7.8/10

Rite in the Rain

Rite in the Rain's lines serve field workers, military personnel and emergency responders as well...

Popularity 6.8/10

uni Brands

The selection suits everyday writers and artists who want ballpoints, gel pens, paint markers and...

Popularity 6.9/10

uni Brands

Its catalogue runs from everyday ballpoint pens to art supplies, serving writers, artists and buyers...

Popularity 1.6/10

Copper and Brass

Copper & Brass Paper Goods sells notebooks, journals, binders, padfolios and financial organization tools, framed...

Wal-Mart Stores

Patterns run from Disney and Star Wars to floral and scenic checks...

Popularity 6.4/10

The Mastery Journal

Its buyers are people who struggle with daily planning, consistent execution and distractions, and the...

Info About Story Supply Co. & Story Supply Co. Store

Most stationery shops resell other makers' goods, but Story Supply Co. designs and manufactures its own notebooks, pads, postcards, posters, pens and pencils. Much of its paper comes from French Paper Co., a family-owned and operated mill that makes its papers with 100% renewable hydro power generated on site. The company describes its aim as supporting sustainable manufacturing in the U.S.A.

The best-known product is the Thick Plot Notebook, sold with black, brown, Horween #8 (Burgundy) or Meadow covers and lined, dot-grid or blank pages. Other notebooks include the Simple Plot Notebook, the Mini plot, the York City Sketchbook and the Pocket Staple notebooks. Pencil options include the Plot Point Hex Pencil Set and the Round-Barrel Pencil, and the company sells replacement elastics and fillers for its notebooks, along with York City t-shirts and Head Bone sticker packs.

Story Supply Co. was founded by Vito Grippi and Gabriel Dunmire, and its team includes writers, teachers, musicians, painters and designers. The team is also part of the group that launched and publishes STORY, a small, award-winning literary journal. Professional graphic design and expert print services are offered as well.

More Popular Products from Story Supply Co.

Prices as of 28 Oct 2026; check the store for current prices.

Company Information

Location: United States

Top Story Supply Co. Product Options

  • Notebooks made in the U.S.
  • Paper from French Paper Co.
  • Renewable hydro powered paper
  • Thick Plot Notebook
  • Horween #8 leather covers
  • Dot-grid lined and blank pages
  • Plot Point Hex Pencil Set
  • York City Sketchbook
  • Graphic design services
  • Print services