
Top Supernatural Alternatives and Similar Sites like supernaturalkitchen.com
Dye-free baking ingredients make up the Supernatural line, with plant-based food colors, sprinkles without titanium dioxide, natural flavorings and melting morsels. Made in the USA, they suit home bakers and food businesses.
Supernatural alternatives
Instya is reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you shop through links on this page.
FarmSteady
FarmSteady invites culinary enthusiasts to embrace the art of crafting artisanal foods at home.
Hamilton Beach
Hamilton Beach sells a kitchen appliance range that reaches beyond toasters and blenders, including electric lunch boxes, electric spiralizers, electric knives and odor eliminators.
All Things Barbecue (ATBBQ)
All Things Barbecue (ATBBQ) combines passion and expertise in grilling, ensuring an extensive selection of high-quality equipment, seasonings, and accessories.
King Arthur Baking
Flours, baking mixes, ingredients, bakeware and kitchen tools for home bakers, with recipes and baking classes.
King Arthur Flour
King Arthur Flour is dedicated to shaping a sustainable future through its initiative, Grains for Good.
Bakery Supply
Perforated tart rings, Silikomart silicone molds and Martellato polycarbonate chocolate molds are among the pastry tools that lead this bakery supplier's stock.
LorAnn Oils
LorAnn Oils sells concentrated, professional-strength flavorings, food colors and essential oils for home bakers, candy makers and commercial kitchens.
RUF
RUF sells baking mixes, mug desserts, porridge and muesli through its online shop, along with seasonal baked goods and Advent calendars.
RedManShop
Starting with its own Redman label flours, sugars and butter, RedManShop sells baking ingredients, bakeware and wines to home and professional bakers, and adds a Baking School, live seafood preorders and holiday turkeys to the mix..
Gygi
Gygi has operated since 1945, and its selection serves home bakers, chefs and hobby cooks...
Cake Connection
Founded in 2007 by decorator Diane Simmons, with her family involved in the business, and...
Santa Barbara Chocolate
The company sells in bulk as well as in smaller packs...
Erika Baking Equipment
Its customers include chocolatiers, pizzerias, kosher bakeries and pet treat makers, and the company pairs...
Inkedibles
Inkedibles manufactures its own edible ink and also supplies commercial labelling and packaging customers, as...
Bakester
From bespoke cakes for celebrations to ready-made treats for the office, each creation is designed...
KneadIt
The blog is run by a former project manager who turned to baking full time...
Cupcake Jemma
Engaging with the community through monthly live bake-alongs and exclusive recipes fosters a sense of...
Fancy Sprinkles
Founder Lisa Stelly built the range around bold colors and shapes for birthdays, holidays and...
Info About Supernatural & Supernatural Store
Supernatural began with its founder, Carmel Hagen, who loved colorful baking as a child while her mother avoided controversial ingredients. When she grew up, those products had not changed, so she started the company to make kitchen baking essentials from ingredients she could stand behind. The company links artificial colors and preservatives to ADHD and illness, and set out to replace them.
Its food colors come from plants rather than chemicals. Early plant-based hues were weak, so the team hunted for natural sources with more strength, and the resulting colors are 300% more concentrated, resilient and flexible than earlier natural options. Each is tested for heavy metals and pesticides.
The sprinkles are dye-free and contain no titanium dioxide. Flavor Drops are newer natural flavorings, non-GMO and meant for anything from smoothies to frosting, much like vanilla extract. Frostings carry Clean Label Project Certification, and colorful melting morsels complete the baking lineup. Seasonal sprinkle colors also appear in holiday and winter collections.
Everything is made in the USA with traceable ingredients that are vegan and allergy-friendly. Bags, boxes and bulk sizes are sold, and food businesses such as Promix have used the sprinkles. Bulk and foodservice buying each have their own pages, and an Instagram account shows bakers' creations. Carmel Hagen is listed as founder and CEO.
Company Information
Location: United States
Top Supernatural Product Options
- Dye-free sprinkles
- Plant-based food colors
- Natural non-GMO flavor drops
- Clean Label Project Certified frostings
- Colorful melting morsels
- Sprinkles without titanium dioxide
- Made in the USA
- Vegan and allergy-friendly ingredients
- Bulk and foodservice orders




