Top Tinned Fish Club Alternatives and Similar Sites like tinnedfishclub.com

Tinned Fish Club United States tinnedfishclub.com

Tinned Fish Club sells monthly subscription boxes of small-batch tinned seafood, each with three tins from different canneries, paired snacks and recipe cards. It suits people who want to learn what to do with tinned fish rather than simply eating it on toast.

Tinned Fish ClubVisit site

Tinned Fish Club alternatives

Instya is reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you shop through links on this page.

Spirits & Spice

At Spirits & Spice, we celebrate the art of flavor with our handcrafted cream liqueurs and custom spice blends.

Partner

Gustus Vitae

Gustus Vitae curates a selection of gourmet sea salts, artisanal cane sugars, and fine seasonings, each crafted to elevate culinary experiences.

Partner

Formaggio Kitchen

At Formaggio Kitchen, a family-owned establishment since 1978, artisan cheese and specialty foods take center stage.

Popularity 5.3/10
Partner

Garrett Popcorn Shops

Popcorn fans and gift buyers who want handmade gourmet snacks will find Garrett Popcorn Shops, a Chicago business known for copper-kettle popcorn in flavors such as CaramelCrisp and CheeseCorn.

Popularity 8.9/10

Equal Exchange

Sources fair trade and organic coffee, chocolate, tea, cocoa and snacks directly from small-scale farmers and their co-ops, shipping within the United States to households and organizations, including by the case.

Popularity 8.5/10

SupermarketItaly.com

At SupermarketItaly.com, enjoy free shipping on orders over $99, even for perishable items.

Popularity 8.5/10

Marky's

Indulge in a luxurious Easter celebration with 10% OFF select caviars, gourmet meats, and an array of desserts using code EASTER.

Popularity 8.5/10

iGourmet

Enter your email to receive timely notifications when this exquisite product is back in stock.

Popularity 7.8/10

Chef Rosana

Pairs hand crafted gourmet foods with custom kitchenware and serveware, built around the cooking of Tampa chef Rosana Rivera.

Cajun Grocer

It serves home cooks and corporate gift buyers across the United States who want Louisiana...

Popularity 7.4/10

Brookhaven Market

The Illinois grocer runs four stores with pickup, delivery and catering, serving neighborhood shoppers who...

Crivencar

It suits buyers who want regional gourmet food for home cooking, or as gifts for...

Popularity 6.4/10

Mackenzie Limited

Orders ship within the continental United States...

Popularity 7.2/10

Sicilian Sea Salt

It suits home cooks and food enthusiasts who want a single pure salt for everyday...

E&C's Snacks

Designed for diverse dietary preferences, each snack embodies a commitment to quality and safety, ensuring...

Seijo Ishii

It suits shoppers seeking specialty ingredients, with nationwide delivery within Japan and in-store pickup at...

Popularity 9.1/10

Golden Steer Steak Company

With a rich history reminiscent of San Francisco’s Gold Rush era, our premium steaks, artisanal...

Allchan

Indulge in the rich taste of Jeju black pork, celebrated for its exceptional tenderness and...

Info About Tinned Fish Club & Tinned Fish Club Store

Most tinned fish sold in American supermarkets is familiar, but Tinned Fish Club selects tins that rarely reach ordinary shelves. Its selection spans 204 different tins from 36 canneries in 14 countries, and the picks lean toward small producers, including Portuguese sardines, Japanese mackerel and Baltic sprats. The Tin Map lets members click any pin to meet a cannery and see which tins it sent the club, from Matosinhos harbour in Portugal to Iwate in Japan. Each box also includes gourmet snacks and condiments chosen to go with the tins, along with a card explaining where each tin comes from and how it was canned.

The club began in 2020, when Nick Pontacoloni noticed tinned fish on wine bar menus around Boston and went looking for tins in specialty European and Asian groceries. His wife Anastasia, who grew up in Ukraine, brought the habit of serving tins on the holiday table. Early boxes were packed by hand in the couple's apartment and later in Anastasia's mother's basement, where more than 1,500 boxes a month were packed at the peak. The club moved into a warehouse in early 2025, and in August 2026 Nick and Anastasia handed it to Dave and Vicky. Every tin is opened and eaten in-house before it ships, and any tin the team would not buy again stays out of the box.

Memberships renew automatically until cancelled. Prepaid three-, six- and twelve-month terms bill again at the end of each term, and members can cancel from their account when they choose. Gift memberships are paid once, run for the chosen term and end without renewal. The first box ships on its own, typically within two to five business days, while regular boxes all go out together at the end of each month. Merchandise includes a Tinned Fish Club T-shirt, hoodie and dad hat.

Company Information

Location: Philadelphia, United States

Founded in: 2020

Top Tinned Fish Club Product Options

  • Small-batch tins from 36 canneries
  • 204 different tins sold
  • Three tins in each monthly box
  • Recipe card with every tin
  • Interactive Tin Map of canneries
  • Portuguese sardines and Japanese mackerel
  • Gourmet snacks and condiments included
  • Tinned Fish Club T-shirts and hoodies