Top Walnut Creek Cheese Alternatives and Similar Sites like walnutcreekcheese.com

Walnut Creek Cheese United States walnutcreekcheese.com
Popularity 4.7/10

Makes homestyle foods in Holmes County, Ohio, including fresh baked goods, jams, jarred produce, deli meats, cheese and baking mixes. The Amish Country store serves local shoppers, event hosts and families sending gift boxes to relatives.

Walnut Creek CheeseVisit site

Walnut Creek Cheese alternatives

Instya is reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you shop through links on this page.

OLMA Caviar

OLMA Caviar, based in New York since 2001, is renowned for its exquisite selection of caviar and gourmet foods.

Popularity 2.8/10
Partner

Try The World

Try The World delivers a curated selection of authentic international snacks and treats, sourced from culinary experts.

Popularity 4.8/10
Partner

Gourmet Food Store

Gourmet Food Store presents a curated selection of exquisite global delicacies.

Popularity 6.4/10
Partner

Garrett Popcorn Shops

Popcorn fans and gift buyers who want handmade gourmet snacks will find Garrett Popcorn Shops, a Chicago business known for copper-kettle popcorn in flavors such as CaramelCrisp and CheeseCorn.

Popularity 8.9/10

Equal Exchange

Sources fair trade and organic coffee, chocolate, tea, cocoa and snacks directly from small-scale farmers and their co-ops, shipping within the United States to households and organizations, including by the case.

Popularity 8.5/10

SupermarketItaly.com

At SupermarketItaly.com, enjoy free shipping on orders over $99, even for perishable items.

Popularity 8.5/10

Marky's

Indulge in a luxurious Easter celebration with 10% OFF select caviars, gourmet meats, and an array of desserts using code EASTER.

Popularity 8.5/10

iGourmet

Enter your email to receive timely notifications when this exquisite product is back in stock.

Popularity 7.8/10

The Epicurean Trader

The Epicurean Trader curates a diverse selection of small-batch artisan goods from dedicated producers across America.

Popularity 5.7/10

French Farm

Immerse yourself in the rich culinary traditions of Europe through carefully sourced products that elevate...

Popularity 3.5/10

Market Hall Foods

With over 30 years of sourcing the finest flavors, we celebrate food through recipes and...

Popularity 5.0/10

Formaggio Kitchen

With a meticulously managed cheese cave ensuring optimal freshness, patrons can indulge in authentic flavors...

Popularity 5.3/10

Mantry

Each bi-monthly selection revolves around unique themes, complete with tips and recipes, making it an...

Popularity 2.7/10

Olivelle

Visitors can also participate in engaging cooking classes that enhance their culinary skills while enjoying...

Popularity 2.0/10

myPanier

Enjoy a range of delectable products, from artisanal butter to indulgent candies, designed to elevate...

Greenland Food

From fresh olives to aromatic spices, each item embodies the rich culinary traditions of the...

Joan's on Third

Enjoy convenient online ordering for holiday catering or eGift cards, and experience the joy of...

Popularity 3.8/10

Verveculture

Our curated selection includes unique kitchenware, gourmet foods, and decorative items, allowing you to enrich...

Popularity 3.5/10

Info About Walnut Creek Cheese & Walnut Creek Cheese Store

In Holmes County, Ohio, in the center of Amish Country, Walnut Creek Cheese & Market makes homestyle foods that reflect the simplicity of the area. Its bakery turns out cinnamon toast bread, cherry fry pies and cupcakes, while the deli prepares party trays of meat, cheese, fruit and vegetables. Shelves hold jarred fruits and vegetables, jams and jellies, Uncle Mike's Meat Snacks and Simple Foods organic cake and frosting mixes. The test kitchen publishes recipes for dishes like Beef Barley Soup and chewy granola bars, and the resources section includes instructions for using the bulk mixes.

The business began in April 1977 with a pickup truck and a slide-in refrigerated box. Mark Coblentz, now president, bought a cheese route from a local owner who had already stopped serving it, and he started with about 20 local products and a list of roughly 60 potential customers. He drove to retail stores in Northeastern Ohio, selling cheese and Trail Bologna. When customers asked for more varieties, he expanded the line, drawing on the Christian values and honesty his Amish Mennonite parents had taught him. Walnut Creek Foods, the deli operation, is run under the same leadership.

Online orders are placed through Mudd Valley Cafe, and both the Walnut Creek and Berlin locations offer curbside pickup between 10AM and 4PM, with a personal shopper gathering each order. Grocery delivery runs Tuesday through Thursday, and Mudd Valley Community Rooms can be reserved as one room or two, holding up to 80 people for meetings, showers and graduation parties. Printed brochures cover bakery cakes, cupcakes and graduation cakes, as well as the Holiday Gift Box Catalog for sending Amish Country foods to family and friends.

More New Products at Walnut Creek Cheese

Prices as of 31 Oct 2026; check the store for current prices.

Company Information

Company Name: Walnut Creek Cheese

Location: Walnut Creek, Ohio, United States

Top Walnut Creek Cheese Product Options

  • Homestyle foods from Amish Country
  • Uncle Mike's Meat Snacks
  • Simple Foods organic baking mixes
  • Walnut Creek Foods deli party trays
  • Cinnamon toast bread and fry pies
  • Holiday gift boxes and baskets
  • Mudd Valley Community Rooms
  • Curbside pickup at two locations