Top Mail Order Mystery Alternatives and Similar Sites like mailordermystery.com

Mail Order Mystery Canada mailordermystery.com

Mail Order Mystery sells personalized mail-order mysteries for children, delivered as letters, objects and puzzles from characters in a story. The five mysteries suit kids from about age 8 to 13, and one is pitched at the whole family.

Mail Order MysteryVisit site

Mail Order Mystery alternatives

Instya is reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you shop through links on this page.

Allcircles

Allcircles creates thoughtfully designed furniture and play items that enhance children's learning and creativity.

Partner

Hit Point Press

Venture into the Bellowing Wilds with "Humblewood: Beyond the Canopy" on Kickstarter.

Popularity 6.0/10
Partner

cuddle+kind

Makes hand-knit dolls in Peru from cotton, and each doll sold provides 10 meals for children in need.

Popularity 8.3/10
Partner

Toysrus

Families shopping for toys and baby products across Canada, with in-store locations in Hamilton, Sarnia, Sherway and South Edmonton.

Popularity 9.0/10

Toy Snowman

Toy Snowman is your premier source for action figures and collectibles in Canada.

Popularity 7.5/10

Galerie du jouet

Parents and gift-givers shopping for children from babies to teenagers will find toys sorted by age group, from 0-2 years through 18 years and older.

Popularity 7.3/10

Cmdstore

Stocks collectible toys, action figures, statues and anime merchandise, with lines from Funko Pop, Sideshow, Hot Toys and Hasbro for collectors of pop culture figures.

Popularity 6.6/10

Coco Village

Wooden toys, play furniture and children's essentials for babies and young children, made to encourage creativity, imaginative play and early development.

Popularity 6.5/10

Griffon

Stocks toys, games and hobby supplies for children from toddlers to age 12 and up, plus adult games and puzzles, sold through its website and its 12 physical shops, with deliveries handled by Canada Post..

Popularity 5.1/10

Jigsaw Jungle International

The extensive selection includes over 100,000 puzzles and accessories, catering to enthusiasts of all ages...

Popularity 6.0/10

4th Moon Toys

Our inventory refreshes weekly, ensuring a dynamic assortment...

Popularity 3.1/10

Gifts For Little Ones

Renowned for exceptional customer care, we proudly present an extensive selection of Maileg Mice, Rabbits...

Calendar Club of Canada

Committed to community support, we inspire creativity and connection, making each moment more meaningful and...

Popularity 4.2/10

Hoverboardsonline

With a commitment to customer satisfaction, we ensure every purchase includes a one-year parts and...

Ages Three and Up

Each item is carefully chosen to engage young minds and promote imaginative play, ensuring a...

Heretoserveyou

The shop showcases a curated selection of action figures, Funko Pops, and collectibles from renowned...

Kids On Wheelz

Each product is designed to inspire exploration and fun, ensuring young riders embark on thrilling...

Funique Jouets de science Toys

Curated for curious minds of all ages, it showcases engaging science-related products tailored for young...

Popularity 3.0/10

Info About Mail Order Mystery & Mail Order Mystery Store

Mail-order mysteries for children are the signature product here. Each one arrives as a series of letters, objects and puzzles from characters in a story, and the child is cast as its hero. Five mysteries are offered. The pirate Treasure Hunt! and fairy-tale The Enchanted Slumber suit ages 8 to 13, the espionage Spies, Lies and Serious Bad Guys and detective The Case of the Missing Bigfoot suit ages 9 to 13, and the time-travel Escape the Master Loop is pitched at the whole family.

The business was founded in late 2015 by a Toronto writer and mother who wanted a gift that could hold children's attention against screens. Each mystery includes ciphers to crack, clues to solve and objects to examine, such as necklaces, keys, pirate maps and fingerprint files. The final installment contains a keepsake artifact. Orders ship only to Canadian and US addresses, including APO and DPO addresses, either as an All in One Box or as six weekly letters.

More New Products at Mail Order Mystery

Prices as of 31 Oct 2026; check the store for current prices.

Company Information

Company Name: Mail Order Mystery

Location: Toronto, ON, Canada

Top Mail Order Mystery Product Options

  • Personalized children's mystery kits
  • Letters from story characters
  • Ciphers codes and puzzles
  • Physical clue objects and artifacts
  • Treasure Hunt! pirate mystery
  • The Case of the Missing Bigfoot
  • Escape the Master Loop time-travel mystery
  • All in One Box or Send Weekly delivery